Why was Christ born from a virgin? We are required to accept the dogmas of the Faith. I have not said that it was taught by an Ecumenical Council. Moreover, on July 27, , the Holy Office now the Sacred Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith warned again discussing this issue in a way " It is an open question as to exactly how the birth occurred. I believe anything is possible with God.
Perpetual virginity of Mary
Mary who was born without the original sin would not have to have this penance. I am a believing Catholic and not just giving you a hard time. The loss of the gift of original justice left our first parents and us in mortal sin because it deprived them of the Grace of God, and to be without this gift of Grace which they should have had was to be in mortal sin. Christ passes through the walls in that instance by virtue of his resurrected body, which is no longer limited in the same way as before by time and space. So not only that the LORD could hinder this beeing seen by an animal as He of course could - but that it were totaly impossible for brute animals or technical apparatuses to do so - because they are not capable of a "transcendent experience". The true problem with our limited minds is that we find it difficult to perceive matter in its true nature as wave-particles, yet mathematics and experiments easily solved the problem.
The Perpetual Virginity of Mary - Truediscipleship
And immediately the cloud disappeared out of the cave, and a great light shone in the cave, so that the eyes could not bear it. The Dogma of the Immaculate Conception According to the dogma of the Immaculate Conception, Mary was "preserved free from all stain of original sin" Ott, If the birth was miraculous as it surely was and if Christ came forth without any rupture or harm to Mary's virginity as he surely did , then there is nothing in the Nativity which could have caused pain. Dogmatic Constitution on Divine Revelation Dei Verbum , 8 , so also the data of biological science, evaluated in the light of Scripture and Tradition, can help us to marvel at the inexhaustible richness of the mystery. On another level, immediately after the Birth of Christ, Mary began suffering her seven Sorrows, so the passage could apply there too. Why such is utter nonsense and blasphemy!
Just because it is "given as a proof" doesn't mean it holds together logically AS a proof depending on how you mean "proof". Some things in Scripture have always been seen as metaphors. Its not enough to quote the Fathers out of context, Chris Definitely the Bible affirms that Jesus was born of Mary and this young woman was a virgin at the time of His birth. MacArthur says, "Further evidence that these were Jesus' actual brothers comes from Psalm